I killed HD-DVD

by Phil Long

Sorry HD-DVD fans, but it was me. The family curse returns. Just as my mum killed Father Ted (who died 10 years ago, this coming Thursday), in December I cut off the air supply for HD-DVD leading to it’s inevitable demise in the format war with Blu-ray.

How did I achieve this? I ‘invested’ in a HD-DVD player for the X-Box 360. Shortly afterward Warner took the decision to only release on Blu-ray and just last week Paramount and Universal followed suit, with the final nail in HD-DVD’s coffin being Toshiba canning the manufacturer of HD-DVD players. Thankfully I only bought two HD-DVDs - Superman Returns and Batman Begins, both available on Blu-ray. The ending of the format war is overall good - as buyers now don’t need to worry about what format releases will be available on.

This meant I had to begin the hunt for a Blu-ray player. I’ve avoided buying DVDs for more than a year; but there are plenty of things I want and it seems the catalogue on Blu-ray is pretty decent. Choosing a player I thought would be complicated, but thanks to the helpful posts of AVforums I concluded that the only option at present is - surprisingly - the PS3. The reasons for this are simple; at present existing players are not upgradeable to support future iterations of Blu-ray releases - Blu-ray extras will include interactive Web content which requires an amount of storage, and Internet connectivity, in the player. While the PS3 currently doesn’t support these features for Blu-ray discs it has the hardware to do so - and is firmware upgradeable. Most players available are not upgradeable to the full feature set - though if you’re just interested in watching the film, it’s not an issue.

So, I now have the 40GB PS3 - cheaper than the 60GB and reportedly quieter. I also don’t need the additional USB slots, multi-card reader or PS2 backwards compatibility for what is essentially my Blu-ray player. I’m liking it - primarily because it’s a lot quieter than the 360 (though so are planes taking off, in fairness), but also because Blu-ray discs (BD) are in 16:9 so appear full screen rather than letter box (though that could simply be down to the discs I’ve chosen). I got the Spiderman trilogy for £27 from Amazon - so already I have one more BD than HD-DVD. I also got Burnout: Paradise - which is an awesome game - though lacks the multi-player (other than online) that made it’s predecessors a fun ‘party’ game. Still - that’s what Mario Kart for the Wii will be for.

In other news, saw Tufty’s projector and screen at the weekend - very impressive. Had a 720p source going into it, projecting onto the 104″ screen. Picture was very sharp even at that size - very much like watching at a mini-cinema.

Related posts:

  • This week…
  • Finishing something…
  • Okay, take the picture… “Gotham’s Green”
  • Leave a Reply